SIDEREAL VS TROPICAL SYSTEM

SIDEREAL VS TROPICAL SYSTEM IS LONG CONTINUING DEBATE IN ASTROLOGY BUT WHICH ONE PRECISELY DEFINE THE EVENTS ON EARTH. I THINK ,WELL THAT BOTH ARE CORRECT OR ONE OF THEM IS DIFFICULT TO SAY. FOR THOSE WHO ARE NEW TO IT

SIDEREAL IS VEDIC SYSTEM DIVIDING THE ELLIPSE OF EARTH MOTION INTO FIXED STARS GROUPS OR CONSTELLATIONS WHILE THE OTHER TAKES INTO ACCOUNT VENEREAL EQUINOXES AND THUS RELATIVE MOTION OF EARTH. TAKING INTO CONSIDERATION THE PRECESSION OF EQUINOXES THE CONSTELLATION RELATIVE POSITION CHANGE BY 1.4 OF THE ARCH AND THIS CAUSE A DIFFERENCE OF ABOUT 23 DEGREE CURRENTLY IN WESTERN ASTROLOGY

SO FOR US CURRENTLY THE SATURN IS IN LIBRA BUT FOR THEM IT IS IN SCORPIO . SIMILARLY FOR US CAPRICORN OCCURS FROM 14 JAN TO 14TH FEB BUT  FOR THEM 22 DEC TO 20 JAN . SO THEY ARE IN A WAY DRIFTING AHEAD OF US . BUT MY QUESTION IS THAT WHY CONSIDER THE RELATIVE  VARIATION IN MOTION OF EARTH . CONSIDER THE RELATIVE   VARIATION IN MOTION  OF ALL PLANETS AS ALL OF THEM ARE SPINNING ON THERE AXIS AND IN EACH PRECESSION THERE IS CHANGE IN POSITION.

IF WE DO THAT WE WILL NEUTRALIZE THE NET EFFECT OF ALL THESE ELLIPTICAL PATH CHANGES AND FIND SIDEREAL SYSTEM BEST TO DESCRIBE EVENTS ON EARTH. I FEEL IT IS BEST POSSIBLE  TO EXPLAIN CURRENT EVENTS BY ASSUMING SATURN IN LIBRA E.G CHANGE IN JUDICIARY SYSTEM IN INDIA, INCREASE IN INCIDENTS OF RAPE (SATURN RAHU CONJUCT IN LIBRA ) , ETC , INCREASE IN INFLATION AND DETERIORATION OF CONDITION OF MASSES(SATURN-RAHU CONJUCT).

SECONDLY AS THE CONSTELLATION IS FIXED AND EARTH IS CHANGING ITS ELLIPTICAL PATH RATHER THAN SHIFTING THE ZODIAC BACKWARDS ITS BETTER TO CHANGE OF MONTHS BACKWARD LIKE JANUARY BEGIN ON 15 DEC AND SO ON AND IN THIS WAY AFTER A PASSAGE OF FEW CENTURIES THE SIDEREAL AND TROPICAL SYSTEM WILL UNITE. BUT  TO SO IT WILL CREATE CHAOS IN KEEPING TRACK OF TIME THAN WHY CREATE CONFUSION WITH ZODIAC LET US CONSIDER THE SOME TOTAL OF ELLIPTICAL PATH CHANGES OF ALL PLANETS AS NEUTRALIZED RATHER THAN CONSIDERING THE CHANGE IN PRECESSION OF EQUINOXES ON EARTH ONLY AND IN THIS WAY SIDEREAL AND TROPICAL SYSTEM WILL REMAIN SAME AND LOT OF PEOPLE WILL BE AVOIDED OF CONFUSION IN ZODIAC  DIFFERENCE BETWEEN WESTERN AND VEDIC ASTROLOGY

AS FOR ME I BELIEVE SIDEREAL SYSTEM AS MORE ACCURATE NOT THAT I AM INDIAN BUT BECAUSE IT GIVES MORE ACCURATE RESULTS

AS FOR NOW ITS A OPEN SESSION. PLEASE POUR IN YOUR COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS.